How to Turn Critiques into Helpful Comments

She just heard your presentation to the Rotary Club and is telling you that you were too quiet, didn’t get to the point quickly enough or lacked a compelling example.

Your breathing goes shallow and your body stiffens, your heart speeds up, and you look around to see if anyone is in earshot of this conversation. You worked for days trying to perfect this presentation—days!

Faced with the often-difficult experience of critiques—in our work and personal lives—many of us respond in unproductive ways. But taking in feedback from others, both positive and negative, is imperative if we are to experience the satisfaction that comes with enhanced competence and improved relations.

Believe it or not, it is possible to think positively when someone critiques you!

When given difficult feedback, most of us find that we do one or more of the following:

Pretend. We say little, disguise any hurt or humiliation, push the feelings way down and eventually act like it never happened. Thank you so much for sharing that.

Defend. We justify our actions, give explanations, point out reasons. There was so much happening last week, I didn’t end up with nearly the time I needed to prepare. Oh, and the microphone didn’t seem to be working well today.

Deny. Denial automatically makes the other person wrong. I didn’t see a problem; I’m great at what I do.

Interrogate. We ask for proof that there is any truth to the feedback. Well, if you want me to understand what you’re trying to get at, I’ll need some specific examples.

Lash out. Anger is the first reaction for some. Get off my back, will you? How dare you criticize me, you of all people! I thought you were my friend.

Criticize. We go on the offensive through blame, innuendo or other unsolicited com- ments. I never believe anything those hotshots have to say. You know how it is in that department.

Self-destruct. We turn all our negative reactions inward against ourselves. I am such a loser. I’ll never get it right. I’m never doing another presentation.

All of these reactions serve to distract us from painful feelings of not being good enough, as well as the notion that we need to change in some way. But adapting to feedback is critical if we are to succeed in our jobs, our marriages, our family relationships.

But we can take the dread out of receiving feedback—and turn “feedback” into “food for thought”—with as little as a simple twist of words. “I wonder what’s going to happen” can become “I worry about what’s going to happen.” We can also make slight shifts in beliefs, such as “all feedback is a gift.”

Here are some guidelines that can help transform feedback into food for thought:

Track your own reactions. Recognize your emotions and responses. What body sensations, thoughts, emotions arise? Recognize that whatever arises in your mind is your own responsibility. You get to choose how you think and respond.

Get support. Ask trusted friends or a professional to listen, encourage and offer suggestions. Even in settings in which people are expected to be self-reliant (such as many jobs), it’s nearly impossible to make significant change without support.

Listen with an open mind and heart. Without affirming or negating the perception of the person giving feedback, simply listen and take in what he or she has to say.

Change defensiveness to curiosity. Don’t explain or de- fend yourself. It may be appropriate to bring the subject up later, if explanations are appropriate. For now, though, say the three magic words: “Tell me more!” Don’t assume you know what the other person means; ask questions to clarify your understanding.

Regard all feedback as an act of generosity. Feedback can help you recog- nize habits that may need to change. It can prompt you to re-examine how you are living your life. It is a wonderful gift. Consider offering sincere appreciation for to the bearer of feedback, even acknowledging how difficult it may have been to deliver the news.

Focus on the message not the packaging. Feedback may be given harshly or by someone with whom we struggle. Perhaps there is a mixture of truth and personal distortion in what we are told. Forget about what package the message comes in; what is the message? What can you learn? Contemplation is a critical step to integrate the message.

Reframe the feedback. When we put feedback in a positive light, negative emotions and responses lose their grip. For example, the feedback on your presentaion could help you improve your chances of promotion. Or, the feedback may point you to greater personal success in a position that does not require presentation skills.

The bottom line: Taking feedback to heart puts you in control and takes you out of helplessness. It may require ruthless self-honesty and a little detective work, but the payoff is high.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: